The latest news about Maine lakes and ponds.

No Secret Deal for Presumpscot's Future

December 12, 2007 - A recent column from Friends of Sebago Lake got several things wrong about a new plan. Making at least four fundamental mistakes in his Thanksgiving Day article in this newspaper, Roger Wheeler, president of the Friends of Sebago Lake, totally misses the mark in his criticism of the state of Maine.

Wheeler misstated the conditions around our cooperative work to restore fisheries to the Presumpscot River through our "framework agreement" announced this summer. If finalized, it will result in removal of the Cumberland Mills Dam in Westbrook and re-establish, for the first time in over a century, native fish species in Westbrook and upstream.

The framework for settlement announced this past summer by the Maine Department of Marine Resources is not a result of secret negotiations between the State and Sappi Fine Paper North America, owner of the S.D. Warren mill in Westbrook. It is the result of over 10 years of hard work by not only the Maine Department of Marine Resources, but also by our federal partner the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and two river conservation organizations. Friends of the Presumpscot River and American Rivers. It is also the result of S.D. Warren being prepared to work out a fair and equitable way to meet its environmental responsibilities and avoid further, protracted litigation.

This framework for settlement is not final, as Wheeler alleges. It is a document guiding current discussion we all hope will lead to a final settlement in 2008. Contrary to what he asserted, the state will hold a public scoping meeting prior to finalizing any agreement, as we have done with other river restoration agreements. We will be reaching out to the public and municipalities along the river early in 2008 to learn more about thoughts that all stakeholders might have.

The Maine Department of Marine Resources is proud of the provisions contained in the framework and excited about the opportunities that communities along the river will have as a result of it. The allegation that the framework agreement does not contain specific passage dates simply in not true.

The document spells S.D. Warren's responsibility to remove the Cumberland Mills Dam in 2011 and to build a fish lift at the Saccarappa Dam in Westbrook, the next upstream dam, in 2016. As the population of sea run fish continues to increase, S.D. Warren would begin building fish lifts on the upriver dams as early as 2026. That period is biologically justified based on the life histories ofthe target species.

The framework is designed to restore all sea run fish, most notably alewives, shad and blueback herring, but including any stray Atlantic salmon as well.

Friends of Sebago Lake is not correct in stating that S.D. Warren's current licenses to operate its dams are for 30 years, and that therefore the 50 years provided in the framework was some type of a sellout by the state. FOSL is well aware of the license details (as they participated in the FERC process in which the license terms were set), so they must know that FERC issued 40-year licenses to S.D. Warren. Why would the state agree to extend these licenses to 50 years if a final settlement is reached? Because FERC routinely issues 50-year licenses when licensees will be expending major amounts of capital to meet license conditions.

What the department, and other participants, did in this circumstance is similar to what has been done in other rivers: working cooperatively to restore sea run fisheries to an important Maine dver.

We encourage the members of Friends of Sebago Lake and all other citizens interested in this fisheries restoration effort to attend the public meeting. To be notified of its date and location, call (207) 287-9972. - Special to the Press Herald

ABOUT THE AUTHOR George Lapointe is commissioner of the Maine Department of Marine Resources. The framework is designed to restore all sea run fish, most notably alewives, shad and blueback herring, but including any stray Atlantic salmon as well.

SOURCE: PORTLAND PRESS-HERALD

DATE: 12-03-2007


Lakes: Sebago Lake
Regions: Sebago


Print this story

Email this story

return to Lake News